Maybe not this year. But like Fins4ever and I were discussing in another thread. There are some really good kickers coming out of college this year. Caleb Sturgis of UF and Dustin Hopkins of FSU. I wouldn't mind spending a late round pick on one of them.
Absolutely. I have read a few articles on the trend going on with kickers. Basically, they are getting stronger and more accurate.
There is also a trend in the NFL to use a late round pick on a kicker. Heck, the Raiders used a 1st round pick on Janikowski.
I am not saying get rid of Carp or make a knee jerk reaction based on one or two games, but like anyone else, he needs competition. Honestly, if you look at his career stats, they are about average.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sebastian_Janikowski