A loss for the Dolphins.
If you watch the America's game documentary on the 72 Dolphins, one of the players, I think it is Manny Fernandez, says that the team's anger over that play came not because of the blocked kick, not because of the pass, but because he didn't throw his body at Mike Bass when he was going down the sideline
I believe you're correct, IIRC Keuch was also pretty angry for him not doing that as well. I think the Dolphins really wanted to go out with a prefect, unblemished mark and keeping WAS off the board for that game would have been icing on the cake. Would have been sweet to win that SB 17-0 (if Garo had converted) and be 17-0 on the season.