Super Bowl Live Blog

[CF DolFan]

1:14:49
1:19:47
What the H man, give credit where credit is due!

OOPs .... didn't see your post. Thanks to Tenshot's post I meant! 

[Spider-Dan]

We will never agree on anything if that picture of the receiver with his elbow and knee on the ground constitute being in the air in your opinion.

I meant "in the air" as in "they are still falling."  Surely you are not arguing that his knee being down means anything in the context of this play.

Again we will never agree if you think 10% is a lot.

You think a 10% failure rate on replay reviews is acceptable?  The referees' union would love for you to be in the league office.

For some contrast: Mike Pereira got 49 of 50 calls right (as in, matching the call made on the field) in his first year as an analyst.

[Rich]

So you say he was in the air at that moment also? If not, thanks for adding nothing to the discussion I'm having.

It is clear from the video that the ground caused the ball to move.

Maybe you should get up to speed on the rulebook if you want to add anything to the discussion.

[Phishfan]

It is clear from the video that the ground caused the ball to move.

Maybe you should get up to speed on the rulebook if you want to add anything to the discussion.

I had a good belly laugh. At best, it is inconclusive. You should remember this before you start telling people to consult the rule book, not even the replay officials said it was incomplete. The official announcement was the call stands, not it was confirmed, so it wasn't even clear to the people making the call apparently.

[Rich]

I had a good belly laugh.

Said the guy who dismisses video evidence and relies on stills...

How does it feel to go thru life relying on incomplete information?

[Rich]

Since you like STILLS, here is a STILL showing the nose of the ball touching the ground.



If you STILL want to argue that the ball didn't touch the ground after this STILL, which shows something different from your STILL, then you can STILL do that.

[Tenshot13]

You guys are STILL talking about this?

[Rich]

You guys are STILL talking about this?

 

[Phishfan]

Said the guy who dismisses video evidence and relies on stills...

How does it feel to go thru life relying on incomplete information?

Says the guy who only takes one angle views and considers it complete. You have no idea what I have considered and your still only shows two fingers of an entire hand. That proves even less than my picture.

I'm not going any further on this. Unless someone can show the other angles this is pointless because one angle doesn't tell the story.