He leaves Miami, Fins are 1 game better than last year with him. He goes to Detroit and the Lions still finish under .500 with him. Regardless in both places, little impact made by him and neither were or are playoff teams.
He is a marginal RB at this stage in his career who is often injured
He's well above marginal, and 5X better than anyone on Miami's roster. I think he did have quite an impact early on for the Lions, and you really can't hang Detroit's season ending collapse entirely on him. Yes he does miss time due to injuries, and had some fumbling problems down the stretch, but I still wish Miami had him. More importantly he has some leadership ability, something sorely lacking in Miami.