Hes not the same guy he was a few years ago.
In 2004 he was awesome, his problem last year was his HR total. That can be attributed to a few things:
1) He doesn't brush people off anymore
2) Harder hitting league
3) Tipping his pitches
He tipped his pitches a LOT last year, ESPN even had a few segments on it during the playoffs. It would explain his first playoff start. If Randy Johnson gets roughed up the world doesn't stand still. However, when he is throwing 94 MPH sliders UP and AWAY and they are being crushed for Homeruns, the batter knows what's coming. Gotta blame Mel Stottlemyre for not finding out what it was.
Plus, he is a bit more comfortable in NY and while he won't go back to 2004 form, I think he will find a nice medium between 2004 and 2005.
Pavano is still useless trash.