Most Under-Rated Dolphins Player? (All-Time)

[jtex316]

Which Dolphins Player was the most under-rated to you?

I have a few that pop-up in my brain.

Dick Anderson - Of all of the Dolphins' lore players, when was the last time you heard anyone talking about Dick Anderson? He was a very under-rated DB and a defensive field general.

Jay Fielder - Everyone hates jay Fielder. Guess what? He's the best QB you've had since Dan Marino, including your current QB line-up. He was successful as a starting QB, very intelligent, and played his ass off. No natural talent, but a lot of desire and passion for the NFL game. And for his team. He got the blame when the idiots around him sucked, and got run out of town because of it. A casualty of a situation that was about to go very bad. And did you know he is former NY Knicks player Anthony Mason's step-brother (or half-brother)? Yeah that's very strange to me too.

Tim Ruddy - I think he started like 100 games in a row or something like that? You never really heard anything bad about Ruddy, which for an O-Lineman, that's high praise. And, for a period of time, he looked like Fausto (I'm not even kidding).

That is all for now. How about you?

[MyGodWearsAHoodie]

who stole jtex's computer? 

[Tepop84]

I agree with Jay Fielder.  Look at his record as the starting qb vs. the people who were brought in to replace him (griese, lucas...)  He knew what it took to win the game. 

[Sunstroke]

Joe Toledo...

(Mark my words...he'll be back!)

[ToticoLicker]

Harry Galbreath.  That guy was a beast at guard back in the old Shula days.  Then the Packers gave him big money in free agency and off he went.

[Dave Gray]

Reggie Roby.

[Tenshot13]

Brock Marion.  I feel he was always overshadowed by Surtain and Madison, but was a great ball-hawking safety.

[Defense54]

Oronde Gadsden.........he made Jay fielder look good.

[ethurst22a]

DB Curtis Johnson - Curtis Johnson holds the Dolphin Rookie record with 6 picks, was a hell of a special teams player (returned two blocked kicks for TD's and almost NEVER got beat on game day. Johnson's assignment in practice was covering Paul Warfield. Enough said.

When Jake Scott and Curtis Johnson went out with injuries in the Sea of Hands game, Oakland attacked them down the middle of the field and with Cliff Branch.

DB Dick Anderson - I agree with Jtex. Anderson and Jake Scott should be in the HOF. Anderson had amazing range for a DB.

QB Jay Fiedler - for the life of me, I don't understand all the hate for Jay Fiedler. Marino threw pick sixes and interceptions. Jay was tough. He played that first year with a torn rotator cuff and had to hand the ball off akwardly to Lamar Smith.

Chan Gailey knew what Fielder was effective at and what he wasn't which led to an 11-5 record that first year.  If Fieldler had not got hurt in that classic game in Denver, I'm sure that Miami would have made it to the AFC Championship.

T Jon Giesler - Jon Giesler was a tackle that just overpowered you. He played on those early 80's Super Bowl teams. When Giesler made a block, he would push the guy six years downfield.

[fyo]

QB Jay Fiedler - for the life of me, I don't understand all the hate for Jay Fiedler.

Was Fiedler really hated though? Or was it just fans being frustrated with the front office being completely sold on him? If you have a good-but-not-great quarterback, you should be working seriously to find a new one. And you could argue that even if you have a great one, you should probably still be seriously looking into a backup. It only takes one play.

I don't recall people blaming Fiedler as much as they were blaming Wannestedt for being married to the guy.

[bsfins]

^^^ Nope, I hated Jay Fiedler also....

[JVides]

How about Bernie Parmalee?  UPS driver makes the roster, plays special teams for a few years, then becomes the starter at running back for a couple of years.

All that for an undrafted guy from Ball State.

[doctord56]

I'd say Jon Giesler, a forgotten yet superb left OT....he never got the love Richmond Webb did, and never gained serious consideration for the ring of honor. But he protected Griese, Strock, Woodley, and a young Dan Marino like a suit of armor from 1979 to 1988 in his 10 year career, starting 105 games.  During the days of all the Marc Gastineau hype of the "New York Sack Exchange", Giesler would own and shut down the loudmouth preening Gastineau.

A terrific and largely forgotten Offensive line cornerstone player of the 1980's fins.

[bsfins]

good call Jvides...May not have been great....but I like the suggestion

[Guru-In-Vegas]

Jay Fiedler?!

Did you guys ever see him throw?  Like, you know, how a quarterback is supposed to?  His win/loss percentage means nothing.  Trent Dilfer won the Super Bowl, so is he an underrated QB or one that just happened to play on a team with an awesome defense and solid running game?  I'm going to go with the latter for both Dilfy and Fiedler. 

In fact, I vividly remember everytime Jay would drop back to pass I'd immediately think "interception".  Most of the time I was wrong since most of the time it landed incomplete.  More times than I would like though, I was right.

Better than Henne?