What Dolphin do you not want on the roster in 2011?

[CF DolFan]

I think Crowder gets much more criticism than he deserves. He is a solid player.

[Sunstroke]

I'll jump on the undeserved criticism pile then...I'd love to see Channing Crowder somewhere else.

[Jim Gray]

I don't hate Crowder, and I think he's a serviceable guy.  But since you asked for a name, that's what I came up with up.  Right now, there aren't  a lot of guys on the team who stand out as being a detrimental weak link.  Most of the players are okay, just nothing special.  Crowder gets attention because he runs his mouth.  Some of the stuff he says embarrasses me as a Dolphin fan (i.e. - his comments after the trip-gate). 

Some may point out Henne as a weak link, but I think we still need him on the roster in 2011........either as a backup, or as the starter if we are unable to improve at the position.  No point in dumping players when there isn't an option to upgrade.

[Tenshot13]

Benny Sapp...just not a good player and I'd rather give a younger, up and comer a chance.  He makes the occasional big play, but gives up more big plays.

[Dave Gray]

Don't hit me, but I think mine might be Ronnie Brown (or RUNNY BROWN, as he's known in some circles).  I think he's a good player, but if we go back to a cap, I'm just not sure he's worth what he will cost.  He isn't the game-changing player that we've been playing for.  I think he doesn't bring much more than a free-agent type back.

[Phishfan]

I'm surprised so many people are picking players who would add some depth even if moved into a backup role. I'd have to say I don't want Pennington on the roster next year. The guy did a great service to us one year, but his time is over.

[Jim Gray]

I'm surprised so many people are picking players who would add some depth even if moved into a backup role. I'd have to say I don't want Pennington on the roster next year. The guy did a great service to us one year, but his time is over.

I'd like to change my vote.  I forgot about Pennington.   

[Brian Fein]

I'd like to change my vote.  I forgot about Pennington.  

Yeah, me too.  But, at the same time, I still don't want Ricky around.  After what he put out in the media earlier this off-season, I'm not interested in having players like that.  And, he's not the Ricky of old.  He runs out of bounds, avoids contact, and is generally slower.  If he had a better attitude, so would I.

[jtex316]

Looks like the Dolphins have some cleaning house to do:

Ronnie Brown
Ricky Williams
Chad Pennington
Channing Crowder

These guys are all older and 3 of the 4 were the mid-2000's "core" players. It's 2011 and I think the Dolphins need to do some mini-house keeping here.

[Doc-phin]

If you watch Crowder, he is pretty damn good at pointing out where the play is going and getting his guys adjusted.  He is a solid tackler and although he isn't an interception machine he doesn't get burnt in coverage.  I say keep him a little longer!

Ronnie is a guy I am ready to see go.  Really Ronnie and Ricky since I always worry about Ricky dropping the ball and am not a fan of his attitude.  Both are slow and overpaid.  Time for some speed and elusiveness at that position.

[fyo]

I'd love to upgrade over Crowder, but he is serviceable and we don't have anyone ready to step up. If we want to be a contender, we need to get his upgrade in place before getting rid of him.

[Phishfan]

we need to get his upgrade in place before getting rid of him.

Now that is just too rational for this group. You should be yelling about walking papers.

[JVides]

^^^Now, now...I led the charge on the Crowder brigade, but I specifically stated that he's so far down the list of upgrade needs that if they get around to him, it must mean they've upgraded at the "really need" positions.

[masterfins]

Don't hit me, but I think mine might be Ronnie Brown (or RUNNY BROWN, as he's known in some circles).  I think he's a good player, but if we go back to a cap, I'm just not sure he's worth what he will cost.  He isn't the game-changing player that we've been playing for.  I think he doesn't bring much more than a free-agent type back.

I don't think he will cost that much.  His numbers last year were pretty unimpressive for a former 1st round draft pick, that added to his past injuries, I don't think other teams are going to be offering him big bucks.  Unless the Fins get lucky and draft a good RB I think he'll be back.  Hopefully, the new O-Line will open some 5 yard wide holes for him to run through.

[masterfins]

I'm kinda with Brian.  He's not a superstar, but when he's out, I think you feel it.

Well thats using a little false logic, by assuming the Fins won't bring someone in to replace him.