That's where you're wrong. In limited action in 2009, he showed flashes of being able to be a dominant runner. He's a powerful runner that also has some springs in his legs.
Being stuck behind Ricky and Ronnie doesn't give you much in the way of opportunities.
He wasn't stuck behind either of them. In 2009, when Ronnie went down, he had a golden opportunity to win the starting job. He played in 7 games after Ronnie went down. The first two games were
decent:
@CAR: 4rush/24yds
@BUF: 5rush/22yds
He was
clearly not as good as a 32-year-old Ricky, but he was, at least, serviceable.
And then the wheels fell off.
vs. NE: 5rush/12yds
@JAX: 2rush/3yds
@TEN: 3rush/7yds
vs. HOU: 3rush/12yds
vs. PIT: 1rush/9yards
That is why he got exactly zero carries in 2010.
Hilliard is total garbage as a running back and I look forward to him proving otherwise.