Henne or Moore

[MikeO]

Sanchez who couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat is better than Moore?  I don't buy that either.  The guy's best play is bounce it off a defender and hope it hits somebody on his own team.

When Matt Moore GETS to a playoff game wake me up. Sanchez has won 4 and played in 6. If you still want to compare these 2 as somewhat "equals" at their position you are lost on this issue. Totally LOST!

Sanchez might not be a superstar, but he is in a class Moore would dream to be in. A much higher class than Matt Moore

[MikeO]

Kolb who couldnt do crap with Larry Fitzgerald is better than Moore? You've lost it, buddy.

Guy's been hurt all year. Starting a team today, every GM in this league would take Kolb over Moore and its not even up for debate.

[BigDaddyFin]

When Matt Moore GETS to a playoff game wake me up. Sanchez has won 4 and played in 6. If you still want to compare these 2 as somewhat "equals" at their position you are lost on this issue. Totally LOST!

Sanchez might not be a superstar, but he is in a class Moore would dream to be in. A much higher class than Matt Moore

There are 50 quarterbacks in the league that are better than Mark Sanchez.  Probably a couple playing in the CFL too.

[MikeO]

There are 50 quarterbacks in the league that are better than Mark Sanchez.  Probably a couple playing in the CFL too.

ha ha, sure. Whatever.  That means there are close to 100 better than Matt Moore

[tepop84]

There are 50 quarterbacks in the league that are better than Mark Sanchez.  Probably a couple playing in the CFL too.

What an ignorant statement.

[Frimp]

Ok, Mike, going by your logic, Steve Young sucked. He left the Bucs where he was horrible and went to the 49ers. And I guess that because he sucked as a Buc, once you suck you always suck right? Even though his game improved with the 49ers, he still sucked right? Because that's exactly what you are saying about Matt Moore.

[EKnight]

Wait. I'm confused. Mike, didn't you just post like a week ago that Sanchez was so bad this year that he should be benched and that the Jets were looking at Manning in the offseason going forward? Didn't you, in fact, say Sanchez is having the worst year of his entire career? And now he's in a class Matt Moore "would dream to be in?" Little consistency please? -EK

[BigDaddyFin]

What an ignorant statement.

I'm terribly sorry I was exagerating there are exactly 43 quarterbacks in the NFL who are better than Mark Sanchez and 3 more in the CFL.   

[MikeO]

Ok, Mike, going by your logic, Steve Young sucked. He left the Bucs where he was horrible and went to the 49ers. And I guess that because he sucked as a Buc, once you suck you always suck right? Even though his game improved with the 49ers, he still sucked right? Because that's exactly what you are saying about Matt Moore.

Steve Young was a superstar in the USFL. And the USFL was a decent league! You might not remember the USFL but Steve Young didn't suck. He had 2 down years in TB because TB sucked and had nobody around him. Matt Moore had Steve Smith in Carolina as well as 2 1,000 yard running backs and a great o-line. And he sucked there. In Miami he hasn't beaten 1 decent team all year. Stop making up silly debates and shooting them down when I never made such a claim about Steve Young.

Matt Moore is a career backup because I have seen him play in Carolina and Miami and nobody will ever say or believe Matt Moore is a future hall of fame player waiting to break out like Young was in TB. Unlike Young, he hasn't shown in the past or at any time in his college or pro career he is noting more than he currently is. He doesn't have that potential. First off, he is always injured. The man can't stay on the field. Second, he has a low ceiling and he has all but reached that ceiling this year.

Matt Moore will have a nice career in the NFL as a backup who can fill in when need be. But to think he can be an NFL starter who will lead a team anywhere or to the playoffs is foolish. He can't. He hasn't. He won't!

[Frimp]

And you will never accept anyone else's opinion that differs from yours with anything other than condescension. You can't, you haven't, you won't! 

[MikeO]

Wait. I'm confused. Mike, didn't you just post like a week ago that Sanchez was so bad this year that he should be benched and that the Jets were looking at Manning in the offseason going forward? Didn't you, in fact, say Sanchez is having the worst year of his entire career? And now he's in a class Matt Moore "would dream to be in?" Little consistency please? -EK

NEVER SAID THAT! Boy you make crap up just to shot it down.  You just re-worded one entire post I put up about a week ago and twisted the entire thing.. I said there was talk in NY about going after Manning next year IF he is on the market. I never said the Jets WERE looking into Manning. That there were rumors. And I said Sanchez is having his worst year to date. Which is a fact. Never mentioned "benching" at all.

And YES, as bad as Sanchez has played "THIS YEAR"....he is still and always will be better than Matt Moore. Not that tough of a concept to understand. Consistent enough for ya.

And for the record....Here is what I said last week

Sanchez is having the worst year of his career. It goes beyond the numbers he has given teams that have no business being in games with them a chance to win or win (ie Denver game).  And until last week he was having so bad of a month there was talk of the Jets trying to get Petyon Manning when he is a FA and possibly moving in a different direction. I still think Sanchez going forward as a player will do very well in the NFL, he is very good. But this hasn't been his year. He still has time to salvage the season though with a strong finish and playoff run.

[EKnight]

And you will never accept anyone else's opinion that differs from yours with anything other than condescension. You can't, you haven't, you won't! 

Amen, +1, /thread. -EK

[MikeO]

And you will never accept anyone else's opinion that differs from yours

why would I "accept" a different opinion? You are entitled to have one, I just don't agree.