I voted 8 too. All sarcasm aside, Tannehill wasn't a NFL QB when he met her and it doesn't matter what she is on the outside, it matters what she is on the inside and no one here is judging that. Marino's wife wasn't all that attractive, but I don't think Dan would have traded her for anyone.
Looking at those pictures of '80s WAGs, none of them were very impressive to me, so I think it's a time thing. They were probably very hot by the standards of the time.
Of course, none of us are judging the nature of her soul by looking at pictures on the internet. That being said, there's no reason that a 9 or a 10 can't be a great person on the inside, too.