Tannehill can't have the 6th best selling jersey in the league.
I have it on good authority that the new jerseys are Horrible And Stupid and Everyone Hates Them.
People are sheep. They are buying into the new jerseys to fit in. Even I almost bought a new polo with the new logo a few weeks ago and I do not like it at all. Carried it around Dick's for about 45 minutes and then returned it as I was heading to the register. I couldn't make that jump just yet although I did purchase a hat with the old logo.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a51bb/a51bb4bef4cf66af9e89e8d852d959e6110808a8" alt="Tongue"
I'm surprised Tannehill's jerseys are selling that well. He wasn't featured much in Hard Knocks and isn't spectacular in any way. He's playing some decent football, sure, but he's not an established star, nor flashy, nor is he lighting it up.
He's the face of our team and his jersey is the most available one out there. If you are
upgrading changing to the new jersey then it's likely his you will be buying.