I think it would be a disgrace if OSU went undefeated for 2 years and didn't make it to the Title Game. Then again, I would also be shocked if Auburn didn't bump them out if they win the SEC Championship next week. I think the Buckeyes are screwed.
The case against OSU is their schedule, but look at FSU's schedule and tell me who the hell they beat. Next week against Duke might be their best of the season because I refuse to count Clemson as a world class team until they can stop shitting the bed in huge games.
If OSU beats michigan st next week, I would think they'd stay in the top two.